Which Mattress Is Good: Spring, Coir, or Foam?


There are many types of mattresses available in the market – Spring, Coir, and Foam are the most common types. Spring mattresses are the oldest type of mattress and have been around for many years. They are made of steel coils that provide support to the body. Coir mattresses are made of coconut fibre and are pretty firm. Foam mattresses are made of polyurethane foam and are softer than coir mattresses.

So, which mattress is good – spring, coir, or foam? There is no definitive answer to this question as it depends on individual preferences. Some people prefer spring mattresses because they are firm and provide good support to the body. Others prefer coir mattresses because they are relatively softer and more comfortable. Foam mattresses are also a popular choice among many people as they are very comfortable and provide good support to the body.

In this post, we will take a look at each mattress type in detail and see its pros and cons so that you can make an informed decision about which mattress is right for you.

Comparing the Spring, Coir, and Foam Mattresses

Spring (Innerspring)

The mattresses in which the inner core is made up of steel springs are called spring or innerspring Mattresses. It is one of the oldest types of mattresses and has been around for many years. The number of springs used in a mattress can range from 100 to over 1000. These springs are designed to provide support to the body by distributing the weight evenly. 

These are made up of 3 – 7 layers (depending on the manufacturer), with the steel coils being the innermost layer. The steel coils are then covered with padding, usually made of polyurethane foam or cotton batting. This is followed by an upholstery layer, which is the outermost layer and can be made of various materials like wool, latex, or polyester.

Spring Mattress

Pros of Using Spring Mattresses

  • More airflow: The hollow construction of the mattress allows for a higher airflow that helps in a better sleep.
  • Durability: The average lifespan of a spring mattress is 8-10 years, roughly doubling that of the foam alternatives.
  • Pressure Release: The spring core supports the entire body; thus no specific region in your body will get pressurized due to uneven support. Due to this, orthopedic patients are recommended to buy spring mattresses as they provide better comfort for back pain.
  • Cost factor: Recent years have seen a decrease in pricing of the spring mattresses, making them more affordable than some of its coir & foam alternatives.
  • Popularity: Being one of the oldest mattress types, The spring mattress has gained a lot of popularity. Due to this, most major manufacturers keep on improving this type.

Cons of Using Spring Mattresses

  • Not good at motion isolation: Due to the interconnectivity of the spring core, these mattresses provide lower motion isolation than foam mattresses.
  • Noise: Springs can sometimes make noise if not properly maintained. Foam or Coir doesn’t require this kind of maintenance.

Who should buy a spring mattress?

If you are looking for a mattress that is more affordable and offers good support, then a spring mattress is a good choice. It is also a good choice if you prefer a firmer mattress or have back pain.

Coir Mattresses

Mattresses which use coconut fibre or Coir are called Coir mattresses. They are made of natural materials and biodegradable, making them a good choice for people looking for an eco-friendly option.

Coir mattresses generally have two layers – the coir layer and the upholstery layer. The coir layer is made of coconut fibre, which is then covered with an upholstery layer. This upholstery layer is usually made of cotton, wool, or polyester and provides comfort to the body.

How Coir is made

Pros of Using Coir Mattresses

  • Affordable: Due to the easy availability of coconut in India, coir mattresses are more affordable than latex and memory foam mattresses.
  • Eco-friendly: As they are made of natural materials, they are biodegradable and eco-friendly.
  • Good support: Coir mattresses provide good support to the body and are suitable for people with bad sleeping postures.
  • Germ-free: Due to the natural tendency of coconut fibre, coir mattresses are better resistant to germs.

Cons of Using Coir Mattresses

  • Hard Sleep Surface: Due to the rigid nature of Coir, the mattress provides a harder sleep surface than its foam or spring counterparts.
  • Durability: The average lifespan of a coir mattress is 4-5 years, after which they start developing sag in the middle, which leads to poor sleep quality.

Who should buy a coir mattress?

A coir mattress is the best choice for anybody seeking an environmentally responsible and more firm mattress.

Foam Mattresses

Foam mattresses are made of different types of foam like memory foam, latex foam, etc. They provide good support to the entire body and are available at different firmness levels.

Foam Mattress varies from a single layer to multiple layers depending on the manufacturer and the intended use.

Foam Mattress

Pros of Using Foam Mattresses

  • Motion Isolation: Foam Mattresses have good isolation to movements; thus, it limits motion transfer from one section to another.
  • Adaptable to your body: foam can physically change its structure to mold itself to your body, giving good support to different pressure points.
  • No Noise: due to its all foam construction, it doesn’t make any noise or cause a disturbance.

Cons of Using Foam Mattress

  • Heat Retention: Due to its dense structure, foam mattresses are known to retain heat. This can be a problem in hot climatic conditions.
  • Initial Smell: Foam mattresses often have an initial smell which can be unpleasant for some people.

Who should buy a foam mattress?

If you want a mattress with good support and motion isolation, then a foam mattress is a good choice for you. It is also a good choice if you want a quiet sleep environment.

Final Verdict

After comparing all the three types of mattresses, we can say that each type has its pros and cons. Therefore, choosing the right type of mattress depends on your needs and preferences is essential.

Foam Mattresses provide you with good support and motion isolation; It is a good choice if you want a quiet sleep environment or if you are a light sleeper.

A coir mattress gives you an eco-friendly and firmer surface to sleep on. It is a good choice for people seeking an environmentally responsible product or people with back pain.

A spring mattress is a good choice if you are looking for a more affordable option or prefer a firmer sleeping surface.

Thus, we can see that there is no one perfect mattress for everyone. It is essential to choose the right one for you.

Do let us know in the comments which mattress is your preference?

The Right Sleep
Enable registration in settings - general
Compare items
  • Total (0)